What Candidate Experience Says About Your Organization
SCOTT MURRAY, MANAGING DIRECTOR
Nearly every board member, academic administrator, or search committee member has, at some point in their career, been a candidate in a search process. Yet when sitting on the other side of the table, those same leaders can become so focused on evaluating candidates that they can lose sight of an equally important reality: candidates are evaluating them too.
Institutions might assume that a compelling mission, strong reputation, and prestigious title will automatically attract top talent. However, those factors may not be enough to persuade candidates who are already successful in their current roles or have other opportunities to consider. In an environment where hiring processes can feel impersonal and opaque, institutions that lead with transparency, responsiveness, and genuine human connection can distinguish themselves. Competition for experienced leaders remains intense. The most successful searches recognize a simple reality: executive search is a two-way street.
Having spent my career advising governing boards, institutional leaders, search committees, and executive candidates, I have seen firsthand how candidate experience can influence the outcome of a search. Candidates can learn as much about an institution from the search process as they do from the latest national rankings, headlines, or strategic plan. In other words, candidate experience is both a talent and marketing strategy.
Every Institution Is Competing for Talent
Focusing on my area of expertise, but certainly more widely applicable, the strongest leaders in higher education are often not actively looking for their next opportunity, or they may be exploring multiple opportunities at the same time. In either situation, institutions must recognize that recruitment extends well beyond the initial outreach. Effective recruiters and search firms use every interaction to build engagement, communicate the value of the opportunity, and help candidates understand what makes the institution a compelling place to lead. Filling a vacancy does not equal recruiting a leader. Every institution is competing for talent and must ask itself: What makes our institution an attractive next step for someone who is already successful in their current role?
Candidates Are Evaluating the Institution at Every Step
As candidates get deeper into a search, every interaction becomes a data point. Candidates pay attention to the people they meet, the questions they are asked, the way decisions are made, and how communication is handled between stages. Campus visits, informal conversations, and interactions with leadership can be particularly revealing. Collectively, these experiences provide candidates with a window into the institution’s leadership philosophy, governance, decision-making, and organizational culture.
For example, an institution may tell a candidate that the new leader will have the full support of the president or the leadership team, only for the candidate to hear conflicting messages about the institution’s direction, expectations for the role, or recent leadership decisions during the interview process. Or perhaps a president sets aside only five minutes to meet with a finalist for a cabinet-level position during a campus visit. Mixed signals like these can cause even the most interested candidates to question whether the opportunity is right for them.
Candidates aren’t simply asking themselves whether they like the people they meet or whether they can do the job. They are also trying to determine whether the institution is positioned to support their success. Are institutional leaders aligned? Are expectations for the role realistic? Will they have the authority, resources, and support necessary to accomplish what they are being asked to do? And does the opportunity align with their own professional goals and values?
Your Search Partner Helps to Shape the First Impression
At the executive level, institutions often engage an executive search firm not only to manage the recruitment process, but also to provide strategic counsel throughout the search. The best search firms understand that initial impressions matter. They are often the first meaningful point of contact candidates have with an institution. For a search to be successful, the hiring authority, search chair, and search consultant must have a strong foundation of trust and partnership. The consultant must be able to tell the institution’s story and represent its brand with authenticity and credibility. Rather than trying to “sell” an opportunity, the search consultant should approach candidates with curiosity and a willingness to explore questions beyond the job description. They need to clearly articulate the institution’s priorities, the opportunities ahead, what will be expected of the new leader, and what makes the role uniquely compelling. Just as importantly, they must be willing to have candid conversations about the challenges candidates may encounter. Ultimately, the search partner can help shape the candidate’s perception, but the institution’s leaders and their actions must reinforce the story being told.
Communication Is the Foundation of Candidate Experience
Few things shape a positive candidate experience more than communication and transparency. Institutions and organizations should set expectations early, communicate timelines, prepare candidates for each stage, and provide feedback following interviews or campus visits. Updates should be timely and informative. Prolonged stretches of silence create doubt, particularly when a candidate is considering another opportunity that is moving more quickly. As for transparency, if things change, don’t hide it. Share what information you can, while respecting the confidentiality of other candidates and the integrity of the search process. If a candidate is not advancing in the process, it is better to let them know sooner rather than later. There is a meaningful difference between keeping a viable candidate engaged and stringing a candidate along while an institution struggles to make a decision. Communication should also be consistent and appropriate across candidates at comparable stages of the process. All candidates deserve to be treated with respect and professionalism, regardless of how far they advance in the search.
Reputation Travels Fast and Outlasts Any Single Search
As is the case in many industries, any experienced college or university administrator understands that higher education is a relatively small and interconnected community. Presidents, provosts, deans, and other emerging leaders regularly share their experiences with peers, including their impressions of institutions and the search processes they’ve encountered. A negative search experience can have reputational consequences that extend far beyond a single search. On the other hand, even candidates who aren’t selected can become ambassadors for an institution when they feel respected, informed, and treated professionally throughout the process.
At its core, executive search has always been a relationship business. A positive candidate experience is not simply a courtesy; it is a strategic competitive advantage. Long before an offer is extended, candidates have formed impressions about an institution’s culture, leadership, and values. Those impressions are shaped less by mission statements or marketing materials than by the search process itself. The institutions that attract exceptional leaders recognize that the search process is more than recruiting. It is a reflection of who they are and how they lead. The best searches don’t just identify the right leader. They give the right leader a compelling reason to choose the institution.
NOVEMBER 18, 2026
Scott Murray is a Managing Director at DSG Global. With more than 15 years of experience in higher education and mission-driven organizations, Scott has partnered with colleges, universities, and boards to find exceptional leaders. His expertise spans chancellor, provost, dean, and vice president searches, and he helped build a nationally recognized in-house search practice.
Related articles
-
?>
-
Board of Directors, Insights, Leadership, Nonprofit
Is Your Board Ready to Lead in 2027?
Nonprofit Governance Check-Up: LEE HUANG, MANAGING DIRECTOR As nonprofit boards look to 2027, they see...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Consulting, Insights, Leadership, Thought Leadership
Designing Lasting Performance
Four conditions leaders can create to turn exceptional results into repeatable ones
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Education, Insights, Leadership
What Candidate Experience Says About Your Organization
SCOTT MURRAY, MANAGING DIRECTOR Nearly every board member, academic administrator, or search committee member has,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
For Boards, Search Committees and Hiring Managers, Insights, Nonprofit
The Offer Is Signed. Now Help Your New CEO Thrive.
MOLLY BRENNAN, Global Managing Partner and Practice Leader,Nonprofit and Social Impact Boards and committees invest...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The Executive Edge in Technology
Why communication, alongside technical depth, is increasingly a leadership requirement for CIOs and CISOs JOYCE...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
Leading for the Long Haul
Lessons from Elite Swimmers for Executive Leaders BRYAN J. CHRISTIANSON, MANAGING DIRECTOR As October begins,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Board of Directors, Insights
The Board’s Role in Crisis Management and Scenario Planning
Reputation takes decades to build and seconds to destroy—plan before crisis hits. TANUJA M. DEHNE,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The New Executive Search Frontier: Fashiontainment
The convergence of fashion, media, entertainment, and sports is reshaping the talent profile of the...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
Is Your Organization Set Up for Sustainable Employment?
The Opportunity for All Hiding Inside the Nonprofit Talent Crisis Paul Towne, Managing Director, Nonprofit...
Learn More →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
The Art of Measured Airtime
Christopher D. Lee, PhD, SPHR, Managing Director at DSG Global, is widely recognized as an...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The Uncomfortable Truth: Leadership Roles Have Evolved
How Can Search Committees Keep Up? JULIE SCHRODT, MANAGING DIRECTOR Many industries have a version...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The First Interview Matters
Best Practices for Healthcare Executives Pursuing New Opportunities BRYAN J. CHRISTIANSON, MANAGING DIRECTOR For healthcare...
Learn from Our Experts →