2025 in Review: Key Nonprofit Hiring Trends and a Look Ahead to 2026
MOLLY BRENNAN ,Global Managing Partner and Practice Leader,
Nonprofit and Social Impact
As we close out 2025, one thing is certain: this was a challenging year in the nonprofit and mission-driven sector. Massive upheavals in funding, staffing, and changing priorities and guidelines at the federal level resulted in system change across the entire sector. As nonprofit leaders look to make sense of this tumultuous year and build out strategies for whatever might come in 2026, the DSG Global Nonprofit team has done the same. Below are six trends around nonprofit hiring and organizational changes in 2025 that we expect to see continue next year.
A flood of highly qualified candidates for every opening
Our search teams are noting record high numbers of applicants for every role. But at the same time, it remains as challenging as ever to identify candidates with the right mix of skills, experience, and content expertise. Large applicant pools require more time spent screening and communicating to candidates while continuing to prioritize customized outreach to identify the right people in a sea of potential applicants.
Growing use of – and concerns about – AI in the hiring process
Savvy candidates are leveraging AI for everything from writing cover letters, to identifying and highlighting key words in their resumes, to networking. And AI-based systems are being deployed more frequently to screen and vet candidates. At DSG Global, we aim to leverage AI thoughtfully, using it to enhance our outreach and research capabilities while still ensuring that we have personal engagement and accountability for candidate assessment. But as the AI frontier continues to expand, search firms, candidates, and hiring entities will increasingly incorporate AI platforms and tools into the hiring process.
The demand for skilled fundraising professionals is on the rise
Our dedicated Fundraising & Advancement practice reported a significant increase in searches in this functional area in 2025 in response to funding cuts and a rush to diversify revenue streams. Our team has seen hiring organizations prioritize major/individual donor expertise in particular.
Location is still a challenge
Our team has seen more and more nonprofits work to get people back in the office regularly, but many candidates, even at the leadership level, remain uninterested in relocation or full-time, in-office roles. We counsel that hiring entities are clear about in-person expectations and travel at the outset of any search, as mismatched expectations on this front can quickly derail a process. This includes defining what hybrid means for your organization and specifying travel expectations.
Retirements are continuing to create leadership openings
The demographic shift that has been underway across the nonprofit sector continues, with many long-time leaders departing. This is creating a new cohort of nonprofit leaders with new ideas and vision, but also may pose transitional risks to organizations undergoing a leadership search.
The final take-away from 2025? Uncertainty is the new certainty
Our Nonprofit and Social Impact Practice has seen candidates and leaders start to move away from risk aversion or a desire to stay put because the environment seemed so unstable during the first half of the year to a stance of accepting that, at least for the foreseeable future, certainty is not something that can be counted on. Sitting CEOs are open to new opportunities, long-time leaders are retiring, and organizations are realizing they need new leaders to develop and implement new strategies. We look forward to a 2026 with more opportunities for leaders and new approaches to navigating the external environment, no matter how it changes.
DECEMBER 15, 2025
Contributed by MOLLY BRENNAN, Global Managing Partner and Practice Leader, Nonprofit and Social Impact – DSG Global
Related articles
-
?>
-
Board of Directors, Insights, Leadership, Nonprofit
Is Your Board Ready to Lead in 2027?
Nonprofit Governance Check-Up LEE HUANG, MANAGING DIRECTOR As nonprofit boards look to 2027, they see...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Consulting, Insights, Leadership, Thought Leadership
Sustaining Success by Design
Four conditions leaders can create to turn exceptional results into repeatable ones
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Education, Insights, Leadership
What Candidate Experience Says About Your Organization
SCOTT MURRAY, MANAGING DIRECTOR Nearly every board member, academic administrator, or search committee member has,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
For Boards, Search Committees and Hiring Managers, Insights, Nonprofit
The Offer Is Signed. Now Help Your New CEO Thrive.
MOLLY BRENNAN, Global Managing Partner and Practice Leader,Nonprofit and Social Impact Boards and committees invest...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The Executive Edge in Technology
Why communication, alongside technical depth, is increasingly a leadership requirement for CIOs and CISOs JOYCE...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
Leading for the Long Haul
Lessons from Elite Swimmers for Executive Leaders BRYAN J. CHRISTIANSON, MANAGING DIRECTOR As October begins,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Board of Directors, Insights
The Board’s Role in Crisis Management and Scenario Planning
Reputation takes decades to build and seconds to destroy—plan before crisis hits. TANUJA M. DEHNE,...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The New Executive Search Frontier: Fashiontainment
The convergence of fashion, media, entertainment, and sports is reshaping the talent profile of the...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
Is Your Organization Set Up for Sustainable Employment?
The Opportunity for All Hiding Inside the Nonprofit Talent Crisis Paul Towne, Managing Director, Nonprofit...
Learn More →
?>
-
Insights, Leadership
The Art of Measured Airtime
Christopher D. Lee, PhD, SPHR, Managing Director at DSG Global, is widely recognized as an...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The Uncomfortable Truth: Leadership Roles Have Evolved
How Can Search Committees Keep Up? JULIE SCHRODT, MANAGING DIRECTOR Many industries have a version...
Learn from Our Experts →
?>
-
Insights
The First Interview Matters
Best Practices for Healthcare Executives Pursuing New Opportunities BRYAN J. CHRISTIANSON, MANAGING DIRECTOR For healthcare...
Learn from Our Experts →